Menu

Chocolate Chip

A gooey, rich chocolate center with crunchy, golden-brown edges

$3

Oatmeal Craisin

Because I like craisins better than raisins (gf option available)

$3

Peanut Butter

A no-frills cookie whose ingredients you can count on one hand (v, gf)

$3

Almond Chocolate Biscotti

A modern twist on an Italian classic, with a slightly chewy finish (v, gf)

$2.75

Double Chocolate

A chocolate cookie with white chocolate chips

$3

Triple Chocolate

A decadent chocolate cookie with semisweet and dark chocolate chips

$3

White Chocolate Pumpkin

A cakey, pumpkin cookie with white chocolate chips

$3

Pumpkin Cake

A simple, soft, pumpkin cake cookie

$3

Peppermint Chocolate

A chocolate cookie with a balanced peppermint bite

$3

Kevin's Cookies Logo Logo for a bakery featuring a close-up of a chocolate chip cookie over a white background.

The more you order, the more you save

The prices listed above are for single cookies.

Every dozen you order knocks 50¢ off each cookie — down to our $1.75 best price. For example, a dozen $3 cookies costs $30 ($2.50 each), two dozen cost $48 ($2 each), and the savings keep going until you hit our lowest price.

Three ways to buy

Local pickup

Our cookie operation is split between Pompton Plains and Livingston. If you live nearby, get in touch to arrange for local pickup.

Schedule a pickup

Mail order

Buyer pays shipping

Get cookies delivered straight to your mailbox, packed and frozen the same day they came out of the oven.

Place an order

In the wild

Find Kevin’s Cookies at a local café or coffee shop near you.

Find us in stores